This definitely isn’t a 1, I dunno who hated it. The hang ups I have are

1) there isn’t much variation in it

2) it cuts off at the end (no finish ot it)

3) the bells? are kind of too loud in the mix and diminsh the beauty of the synth sound.

Can you upload that synth sound as a sample? I like it!

The little keyboard melody is pretty interesting. The vinyl effects are pretty good, although I hear a lot of folks do those these days. I like the melody here.
Not a bad song—I’d have gotten a more realistic rain sample, perhaps.