Reviews for "The Lie"
permalink Sat, Jul 9, 2005 @ 12:15 PM
well, it’s totally workable as far as I’m concerned.
however you REALLY need to get a pop screen
Well, as i stated, this was recorded a fairly long time ago, when I didn’t have any decent equipment and also no experience with audacity - so this was all done layered over eachother using arecord *shudder* to record it ;) It’s just here because I thought someone could perhaps do something with it.
I may get a chance to re-record it at some point. If I do, i’ll point to the re-recorded version
edit: Just uploaded a much newer song "Complete" (not accappela) at http://ccmixter.org/file/ky... - i’d be interested in critique of newer stuff
OK, I changed my mind - I tried to work with this one tonight and I just couldn’t get passed the way the vocals were overdubbed on top of one another. The pitch issues could be overcome if they were separate tracks (or at least panned to either side so we could isolate them). I know this is an old recording but to us it’s new and you chose to upload it here so I guess you can expect feedback based on that.
permalink Fri, Jul 8, 2005 @ 4:51 PM
This is a good song and can be extremely brilliant but I personally think another vocalist is needed who is in key all the time. You are there but there are particular notes, which are off. Also the backing up track with the beat box would be great only if it was properly sync’d. With these changes in mind for me this would be a great track to remix.
permalink Sat, Jul 9, 2005 @ 12:09 PM
Song is good, but the track is absolutly bad. tempo trouble, invalid intonation. Self control please.